McAuley Labels vs MyAssetTag: Which One Is Better for Your Business?
When youāre choosing asset tags, barcode labels, or custom equipment labels, two popular options areĀ McAuley Labels and MyAssetTag.
Both offer durable solutions, but they differ in materials, delivery times, customization, and overall value.
Below is a clear, honest breakdown to help you decide which one fits your needs.
ā Quick Comparison Summary
| Feature | McAuley Labels | MyAssetTag |
|---|---|---|
| Manufacturing Location | USA | USA |
| Material Quality | Metalized silver + 3M heavy-duty + laminated polyester | Polyester + vinyl options |
| Customization | High flexibility (logos, QR codes, serialized, full-color) | Medium flexibility |
| Turnaround Time | 1ā3 business days | 3ā5 business days |
| Minimum Order | No minimum | No minimum |
| Pricing | Competitive, especially for custom runs | Higher on most custom orders |
| Customer Support | Fast, personal, phone + email | Email support only |
| Special Products | Oil change labels, test tube labelers, and industrial printers | Basic asset tags + signs |
| Best For | Automotive shops, warehouses, IT, labs, equipment tracking | General asset tagging, signage |
š Verdict: McAuley Labels is Better for Fast, Durable Custom Asset Labels
If you need quick turnaround, heavy-duty materials, and personal customer support, McAuley Labels is the stronger choice.
MyAssetTag is a known name and offers many different stock labels, but McAuley provides better durability, faster shipping, and more customization control.
š Side-by-Side Comparison
1. Product Quality & Materials
McAuley Labels
-
Metalized silver polyester
-
3M heavy-duty adhesive (sticks to textured / powder-coated surfaces)
-
Waterproof, chemical-resistant, and fade-proof
-
High-contrast barcode & QR code printing
-
Made to last years outdoors and indoors
MyAssetTag
-
Standard polyester
-
Vinyl options available
-
Durable but not optimized for long-term chemical/abrasion resistance
-
Materials vary by product
-
Less specialized for equipment exposed to oil, dust, or heat
Winner: McAuley Labels
Better durability and more industrial-grade materials.
2. Customization Options
| Custom Feature | McAuley Labels | MyAssetTag |
|---|---|---|
| Logo printing | ā Yes | ā Yes |
| QR codes | ā Yes | ā Yes |
| Serialization | ā Yes | ā Yes |
| Full-color options | ā Yes | Limited |
| Custom layouts | ā Highly flexible | Medium |
| Personalized support | ā Designer support | ā Automated only |
Winner: McAuley Labels
More flexibility and hands-on help.
3. Lead Time & Delivery Speed
McAuley
-
Ships in 1ā3 business days
-
Fast processing, most orders are made the same day
-
Free express shipping on most orders
MyAssetTag
-
Ships in 3ā5 business days
-
Slower on fully customized tags
-
Standard shipping options only
Winner: McAuley Labels
Significantly faster turnaround.
4. Price & Value
McAuley Labels
-
Competitive pricing on custom orders
-
Discounts for batch/industry clients
-
Lower cost on heavy-duty 3M materials
-
No minimum order requirement
MyAssetTag
-
Often higher-priced on custom orders
-
Some bulk discounts
-
Lower base cost on simple stock labels
Winner: McAuley Labels
Better value for custom, durable tags.
5. Support & Customer Service
| Support Type | McAuley | MyAssetTag |
|---|---|---|
| Phone Support | ā Yes | ā No |
| Email Support | ā Fast | ā Slow |
| Custom Guidance | ā Dedicated help | ā Limited |
| Live Chat | ā Available | ā Not available |
Winner: McAuley Labels
Much more personal support experience.
6. Product Range
McAuley Labels
-
Custom asset tags (metalized, heavy-duty, laminated)
-
Inventory labels
-
Oil change stickers
-
Fully programmed thermal printers
-
Ready-to-go label kits
-
Custom business logo stickers
-
Custom equipment labels
MyAssetTag
-
Asset tags (basic & premium)
-
Signs & safety labels
-
Stock identification labels
-
Some custom formats
Winner: Depends on needs
-
For asset tags + printers + automotive use ā McAuley
-
For signage & generic ID labels ā MyAssetTag
š§Ŗ Durability Showdown
| Durability Category | McAuley | MyAssetTag |
|---|---|---|
| Waterproof | ā Excellent | ā Good |
| Chemical Resistance | ā Excellent | ā Medium |
| UV Resistance | ā Excellent | ā Medium |
| Long-term Adhesion | ā 3M premium | ā Standard |
| Outdoor Usage | ā Strong | ā Medium |
Winner: McAuley Labels
ā Customer Satisfaction
| Category | McAuley | MyAssetTag |
|---|---|---|
| Google Rating | 4.8+ | 4.3ā4.5 |
| Repeat Customers | Very High | Medium |
| Mixed Reviews | Very Low | Medium |
šÆ Which Should You Choose?
Choose McAuley Labels if you want:
-
Fast turnaround
-
Industrial-grade durability
-
Strong adhesives for metal & textured surfaces
-
Custom barcode/QR equipment labels
-
Real human support
-
Automotive, warehouse, or laboratory reliability
Choose MyAssetTag if you want:
-
Basic office labels
-
Signage
-
Not time-sensitive orders
-
Standard polyester tags at mid-range durability
š Final Answer
McAuley Labels is the better choice for businesses that need durable, custom, fast-delivered asset labels designed for real daily use.
Thank you for choosing McAuley Labels
We look forward to being a part of your journey!
Get Sticky with Us